Microwave vs air fryer for leftovers: which one wins
Microwave vs air fryer for leftovers: the microwave wins on speed and soft foods, the air fryer wins on anything that should be crisp. Here is the rule.
Amine Haddad4 min read
Verdict: the microwave wins for wet food, the air fryer wins for crisp food, and neither wins for both. In the microwave vs air fryer question, the food decides. Soup and pizza want opposite things.
A microwave heats the water inside food. That is fast, and it makes crisp things soft. An air fryer blows hot air around the food. That dries the surface, which is what a crust needs. It is slower.
Which wins on
| Factor | Microwave | Air fryer |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Microwave. Often a minute or two | Slower. Usually several minutes, plus a short warm-up on some models |
| Crisp food | Air fryer. The microwave makes it soggy | Air fryer |
| Soups, stews, curries | Microwave. Air fryer would dry them out | Poor fit |
| Rice and pasta | Microwave, with a splash of water and a lid | Dries out easily |
| Energy per reheat | Microwave typically uses less for small portions | Fine, but the longer time adds up |
| Cleaning | Microwave. Wipe the inside, wash the plate | Basket needs washing, and grease sticks |
| Counter space | Tie. Both take room | Tie |
Pick the microwave if
- Most of your leftovers are soup, rice, pasta, curry or stew.
- You often reheat one portion in a hurry, such as a work lunch.
- You do not want to wash a basket after every meal.
- You want something that also defrosts and warms drinks.
Pick the air fryer if
- Your leftovers are pizza, fries, fried chicken, spring rolls or roast vegetables.
- You are tired of rubbery crusts.
- You have time for a five to ten minute wait.
- You already want an air fryer for cooking. Reheating is a bonus.
What each food wants
Think of leftovers in two groups. Wet food keeps its water and needs gentle, even heat. Dry or crusty food needs the surface dried out again.
- Wet food: microwave, covered, stirred halfway. The stir matters more than the power setting.
- Pizza: air fryer for a few minutes. The base crisps and the cheese melts again. In the microwave, the base turns chewy.
- Fries and nuggets: air fryer. These are the classic microwave failures.
- Rice: microwave with a little water. Cooked rice that has sat out for hours is a food safety problem, so chill it fast and reheat it until steaming hot.
- Roast meat and vegetables: either. The air fryer keeps edges crisp. The microwave keeps slices moist. A cover helps in both.
Worked example
You have one portion of curry and one slice of pizza. Microwave the curry for a couple of minutes. Put the pizza in the air fryer for a few. Eat the curry while the pizza finishes. That is the whole routine, and it needs both machines.
With only one machine, ask which pile of leftovers is bigger in your fridge. Buy for that pile.
The difference that matters
Texture. Speed and energy are close enough that they rarely decide anything. What decides it is whether the food should be soft or crisp when it hits the plate. Look at what you threw away last month. If it was soggy crusts, you want the air fryer. If it was dried-out rice and soup you could not be bothered to heat, you want the microwave.
Common mistakes
- Reheating crisp food in the microwave and blaming the food.
- Piling the air fryer basket full. Crowded food steams instead of crisping.
- Putting wet food in the air fryer without a lid or tray. It dries out.
- Skipping the stir. Microwaves heat unevenly, so cold spots are normal.
If you are deciding whether to buy an air fryer at all, read air fryer vs convection oven first. You may already own the machine.
Quick questions
Can I use an air fryer instead of a microwave?
For crisp food, yes. For soup, rice and sauces, not well. It is also slower, so it is a poor swap for quick lunches.
Is a microwave or an air fryer cheaper to run for leftovers?
For one small portion, the microwave typically uses less energy because it is on for less time. Neither costs much per reheat. Ratings vary by model.
Why does pizza get soggy in the microwave?
The microwave heats the water in the dough and sauce, and the steam has nowhere to go. An air fryer dries the surface instead.
Is it safe to reheat leftovers in either one?
Yes, if the food is heated until steaming hot all the way through and was chilled promptly after cooking. Reheat food once.
More to read
Keep reading
Dishwasher vs hand washing: water, energy and time
Dishwasher vs hand washing: a full modern dishwasher typically uses less water and energy than washing by hand, but hand washing wins for small loads.
Amine Haddad5 min read
Induction vs gas hob: which cooktop is better
Induction vs gas hob (also called induction vs gas cooktop): induction is faster and easier to clean, gas works with any pan. Here is how to choose.
Amine Haddad4 min read
Slow cooker vs pressure cooker: which should you buy
Slow cooker vs pressure cooker for beginners: the slow cooker is simpler and forgiving, the pressure cooker is faster and does more. Here is how to pick.
Amine Haddad4 min read
Robot vacuum vs cordless vacuum: which one to buy
Robot vacuum vs cordless vacuum: the robot handles daily upkeep on flat floors, the cordless does the deep clean, stairs and rugs. Here is how to choose.
Amine Haddad4 min read
Air fryer vs convection oven
An air fryer is a small convection oven with a stronger fan. Here is who should buy one, who already owns one, and which factors decide it.
Amine Haddad3 min read
Toaster vs toaster oven: which is worth the counter space
Toaster vs toaster oven: a toaster makes better plain toast for less money, while a toaster oven does small cooking jobs a toaster cannot.
Amine Haddad4 min read